One thing for sure is the software is different. The lack of any normal menu bar may throw some off but the fact that the environment mirrors the open menu structure of the device is a nice integration. However, that’s pretty much where the nice part wears off.
OK, let me be a little more specific here. The Social aspect of it is still very nice. I like that my friends can see what I am playing. MSoft can suggest similar artists in the marketplace for me to check out. Even the ability to listen to beamed songs is nice.
On the flip side, it seems like the software is trying to constantly force me into listening to song in a traditional manner. By artist or Album. Shuffle exists but is just hard to find. Even scrolling to find an artist is a fine art. One place they could have made up for this is in the search feature.
Search, however, is massively broken. Any term I search for looks equally into my library as it does the marketplace. So I am often given items I already own. Double clicking on the song, in my mind, should play the song. Not so here. A double click will bring you back to the top of your library. Not to the song you clicked on, the top of the library.
Podcasts also lack a distinct sense of usability. If I give control of my podcatching to Zune, it is a joy. If I want to use another podcatcher like Juice or integrate PodNova then just forget it. Zune Software must be the center of the Zune universe or podcasts don’t function properly. Oh and why is my Zune Software trying to download somethign when my Zune isn’t even connected? Software updates should happen in the normal fashion and not something that prevents me from closing the software.
In the end, the software is just very clunky, slow to sync items, and is just not very intuitive to the files on my machine. Lets hope the device menus show some ray of usability.